Should prisoners have the right to vote debate. We Need To Talk About... Prisoner Voting 2019-02-18

Should prisoners have the right to vote debate Rating: 4,5/10 166 reviews

Should Prisoners Be Given The Right To Vote Essay example

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

Unless you believe what you said earlier in that all drug charges are unjust. Prison is itself already severe punishment. The idea that maturity is what qualifies a right to vote is just simply false. In the United Kingdom, parliament decided a prisoner earns back his lost rights by serving his sentence—scarcely a slippery slope to medieval punishments. Those on the left might charge that the creation of a prison constituency might take focus off the problems with mass incarceration itself, including the racial and other injustices of our current criminal justice system. If we can use them in other nation building activities, why not allow them to vote? What is the rationale behind such restrictions and balancing exercises if not an acknowledgement of the concept of responsibility? Ones that are actually worth mentioning.


Next

MPs debate: Should prisoners have the right to vote?

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

It implicitly fails to recognise a very relevant dimension of the issue, namely that the right to vote is a fundamental human right. What about people without sufficient mental capacity to vote again, under maturity — are they not human too? Despite this, prisoners are allowed rights,. This argument takes an extreme example to prove its point. It'll make for a good first step in straightening it out so to speak. If we thought criminals could never be reformed, we wouldn't let them out of prison in the first place. In fact, as Liora Lazarus has on this blog in her response to Graham Gee, it was almost impossible to find any discussion which acknowledged the existence of the right and tried to delineate its scope. If you ever engage me in discussion again, I promise not to attack your character.

Next

Should Prisoners Be Given The Right To Vote Essay example

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

Consumers have a vague idea about the process of production of food and where the food actually comes from. In any case, the right to vote does not follow from the obligation to pay tax. Moreover, people who went jail for drunk driving or any other white-collar crime are not deprived of their voting rights, Therefore, only people who committed crimes that show that they are clearly not in a mindset that one would want someone to be in if they going to vote. But going back to prisoners. The debate on whether criminals should be punished or rehabilitated has been discussed for many years now. Many good Conservative friends of mine not least Dominic Grieve, the finest Attorney General of recent years , appreciate that when you join a family of nations like the Council of Europe with a convention and a court, you have to respect even the judgements you disagree with. The minute criminals knowingly and willingly commit a crime, they lose the privilege to certain civic rights, such as voting.

Next

Should Prisoners Be Given The Right To Vote Essay example

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

Under the current system, ending abusive practices requires years of expensive litigation as prisoners sue over maltreatment and prisons adjust to the rulings. If I steal something, I've violated someone's right to private property. Similar to the point illustrated in Niemöllers poem First They Came, if we allow a person or body like the government to decide for themselves who can hold them to account, or indeed if any of us believe we can dictate who is worthy of enfranchisement, then where does this stop? Does that then mean that prisoners lose all their other rights in prison? That means that our laws have been made or approved by democratic institutions. In America, the number of Prisoners in America is 2 million. So when they are sent to prison, the feel like they are lower than other people and that the government doesn't care about them any more.

Next

Prisoners Should Have The Right To Vote

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

So how can such people be allowed to vote? Not all prisoners will want to vote. How are we supposed to expect former criminals to integrate back into society if they are continuously treated like convicts? Some will argue that it is enough to allow prisoners to regain their right to vote after release. Many families now want to live a healthy lifestyle, so prepared meals have become their natural way of life. But I see it as, if we want prisoners to come back into society and be a model citizen then maybe we should let them have a say on the type of society they come back into. Would you give someone who has recently blown someone else up the privilege of voting for the leader of our community? Eating prepared meals can help save money and resources.

Next

The Big Debate: should prisoners get the vote?

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

Medicine became better; schools and education improved, and treatment of our prisoners became more humane. Now when the polls open women and men stand next to each other and cast a vote that holds the same importance. Some people believe that when a person commits a crime, they waive their right to be treated in the same way as others. Fast food has become a regular way of life for many people. Politicians are all about appealing to the majority.


Next

Why prisoners should be given the right to vote

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

This act was known as ' ' Civil Death ' '. The vote is a privilege but is also a right as it's the basis of a functioning democracy so therefore, if prisoners are deemed to no longer be part of society then they should no longer receive the privilege as it is part of the punishment. In 1870, under the Forfeiture Act, prisoners This shows that there is little argument against the disenfranchisement of prisoners as they are prepared and encouraged to be a part of society. James Wilson: There is no argument against convicted prisoners having the vote. This argument fails to take into account the significant number of prisoners who are incarcerated because of minor crimes or crimes that are mala prohibita — wrong not in itself but because it is prohibited by law. This is not something we should look deep into; this is not something that will keep you up at night. How can we equate these minor offences with that of blowing things up? If not what would make a law unjust? Not allowing prisoners to vote, especially once they have been released from prison, is tantamount to marking them as something less than human and unworthy of basic human rights.

Next

Duel: Should prisoners be able to vote?

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

They are required to ensure that all citizens, including prisoners, get their human rights under the Convention. Prisoners have decided to go against the law and withdraw themselves from society, sapping up money from the government for their accommodation and food. Prisoners also retain some First Amendment free speech rights to hold and express political opinions. Grafitti image © , used under Creative Commons Licence. Provide a reasoned argument for your decision.


Next

Should Prisoners Have the Right to Vote?

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

If we really want convicted felons to re-engage with society, become transformed, and feel like part of a broader community, we should do everything possible to re-integrate these individuals into ordinary society. However, Britain has an appalling record of criminals who commit crimes repeatedly. Temporarily forfeiting the vote is a legitimate sanction for imprisonable offences. And debating the purposes of criminal justice only highlights that this is about social policy not fundamental rights. It would be unfair that a whole prison's worth of voters could sway a council or a general election because the prison is so large it would affect the constituency size and count as a large part of the voters in the constituency and it would marginalise the votes of law abiding citizens in constituencies. A prison constituency with rights to vote and related rights of free speech can engage in civic activism that will continue after release. But y ears have passed, and the blanket ban on prisoner voting remains.

Next

Talk It Out: Should prisoners have a right to vote?

should prisoners have the right to vote debate

Even the right to life is not absolute — people can be killed in self defence, for example. They are incapable of making rational decisions, that's why they're in jail. I think that even if they were criminals, They were still born human and they still grew up in the same society as us. Amnesty International has become one of the most successful agencies, freeing and helping thousands of people who have been imprisoned unfairly. I actually have little opinion on the topic myself, so would like to hear some new views on it. A prison constituency will not revoke unjust laws overnight, but it can allow those who are most affected by them and their sometimes unjust application to speak out against them. He is the author of Princeton University Press, 2012 , out in paperback this month, and Princeton University Press, 2007.

Next